Fine Fellows Creamery

313 Beach Ave, Cape May, New Jersey 08204 USA

141 Reviews

View Photos

Budget

Closed Now

Opens Fri 4p

Independent
Credit Cards
Accepted
Pet Friendly
Wheelchair
Accessible
Wifi

Learn more about this business on Yelp.

Reviewed by
Jairo T.

November 08, 2023

Unfortunate to see this shop is temp closed. Went a few months ago and had to drop a review because the ice cream was great. Got the strawberry and coconut. The bold and creamy flavors really... Read more

Reviewed by
Melanie M.

October 22, 2023

End of season (mid-Oct) so thankfully they were still open and still had the salted caramel pretzel ice cream! Cute decor and friendly service. Read more

Reviewed by
John L.

August 05, 2023

We came here to try it out. We got a milkshake and 3 cones -- the bill was $40. Sorry but that is way too much for this ordinary ice cream. And the milkshake was not good for $14. Ok but... Read more

View 141 reviews on