Goodfellas Pizzeria - OTR

1211 Main St, Cincinnati, Ohio 45202 USA

334 Reviews

View Photos

Reasonable

Open Now

Fri 11a-3a

Independent
Credit Cards
Accepted
Wheelchair
Accessible
Public
Restrooms
Outdoor
Seating

Learn more about this business on Yelp.

“Delicious New York style za!”

New York style pizza is large, hand tossed and has a thin crisp yet foldable crust. Goodfellas has mastered this art and presents it to you along with fresh ingredients, homemade sauce, and 100% whole milk mozzarella cheese. We thrive in a fast paced environment, with high energy music, and a friendly community of people gathered for one thing… good pizza. Have it by the slice or bring home a whole 22" pie for the entire family to enjoy. Capisce?

Reviewed by
Rebecca H.

November 13, 2023

I had literally just stepped out of a multiple hour dinner affair at a nearby restaurant but wasn't about to vomit from the quantity I ate so I felt obliged to stop into this place for a slice.... Read more

Reviewed by
Scott M.

September 10, 2023

We was in the OTR, Had lunch. 1st visit to Goodfellows outside of Lexington. Pretty cool Atmosphere. Love the pizza by slice & bourbon bar upstairs is really nice. Nice outdoor patio.. Worth a... Read more

Reviewed by
Lisa R.

March 13, 2024

Amazing!!! Best pizza I had had for a long time!! I'm usually a thick crust but the have the crust science to a T!! Perfection!! We will be back. Service very nice Yelp did great suggesting this... Read more

View 334 reviews on