My Boys Pizza

96 N Mill St, Creswell, Oregon 97426 USA

61 Reviews

View Photos

Reasonable

Open Now

Wed 11a-9p

Independent
Credit Cards
Accepted
Wheelchair
Accessible
Wifi

Learn more about this business on Yelp.

“Try some hot pizza”

30 years ago, Mr. Macho’s, was started in this location by Don Taylor. After a 7 year absence, the Taylor boys decided it was time to bring back the pizzas and sandwiches that made Mr. Macho’s famous…thus, the name My Boys Pizza! My Boys Pizza has gone back to the original homemade pizza sauce and has updated the famous crust recipe to make it even crispier. In addition, the Taylor Sandwich is back along with many of the menu items including the Teen Pizza now renamed the Baby Boy in honor of the third generation of pizza makers (now age 2 years and 14 months). The Salad Bar has increased in size. It is now 13 feet long with more goodies to choose from. If you were a Mr. Macho’s client, you will be surprised to see My Boys Pizza now. The interior has been totally remodeled with new colors and tiled floors. Try us once and you will be back for more!

Reviewed by
Michael B.

December 18, 2023

I love this place. I am recently traveling to Creswell twice a month on business. We brought pizza in from another place for a meeting, not as good My boys. I ordered room service to my hotel... Read more

Reviewed by
Joey H.

February 15, 2024

After coming here half a dozen times it's been a consensus that the service is just terrible each time. Workers are stressed out and you feel it with the establishment, salad bar is not stocked,... Read more

Reviewed by
Mariah F.

January 12, 2024

We got a large pizza with 2 different types. (Chicken, bacon, ranch & pepperoni, Canadian bacon, and beef) We also got a 6 piece buffalo wing. The crust coulda been cooked a bit longer was a tad... Read more

View 61 reviews on