Bagels and Cakes

476 Hamilton St, Geneva, New York 14456 USA

68 Reviews

View Photos

Budget

Open Now

Thu 6a-8p

Independent
Credit Cards
Accepted
No Wifi

Learn more about this business on Yelp.

“Cafe and Bakery in Geneva!”

Club 86 Bagels and Cakes was opened January of 1999. It's the idea of Bill and Lori Legott from CLub 86 Party House, which has been in the Legott Family since 1947. The Bagel Shop is the combination of traditional bagels, featuring kettle boiled bagels, signature sandwiches, charbroiled burgers and italian specialties from the Club... All available for eating in or taking out! Celebrating something special? Check out The Cake Lady, her famous Strawberry Layer Cake is always a crowd pleaser. Whether you are planning a dinner party, casual get together, a corporate lunch, a cocktail reception or a sit down Wedding... The Bagel Shop & Club 86 catering can handle all of the particulars to ensure that you next party is just what you are looking for! Bagels & Cakes ~ Where people gather for good food, quick service and a warm and friendly atmosphere!

Reviewed by
Sharon S.

April 20, 2024

Running between events at HWS, dropped in here for a late lunch. I had a protein smoothie - the banana one (I forget the name). Loved it. It's the next day, and I'm thinking how can I get back?... Read more

Reviewed by
Cody L.

July 27, 2023

Nice local bakery. Bagels were soft and fresh with good flavor. Pancakes were plate sized and good. The Humbert Street Hurley was a good sized sandwich. Bun was soft and flaky the turkey could... Read more

Reviewed by
Seford O.

April 07, 2024

The service was rapid. There were six of us and everyone order a different dish. A friendly place. Seems like a happy hang out for some of the older folks. Will visit it again soon Read more

View 68 reviews on