Mr G's Old Fashioned Ice Cream

404 Baltimore St, Gettysburg, Pennsylvania 17325 USA

170 Reviews

View Photos

Budget

Open Now

Tue 12p-9p

Independent
Credit Cards
Accepted
Outdoor
Seating
No Wifi

Learn more about this business on Yelp.

“Hand Made Ice Cream in Gettysburg!”

Making history one scoop at a time! Mike Gladfelter and Stephanie Glafelter have reopened their ice cream shop at the historic Twin Sycamores house in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania. Stop in for homemade ice cream, shakes, softserve, and sundaes! Check in on our facebook page to see flavors of the day and new announcements in regards to a store that will be opening behind the ice cream shop. Whether you're stopping in for the first time or are a regular, you're sure to have a great time and treat at Mr. G's!!

Reviewed by
phil m.

December 09, 2023

Always a great selection of flavors, Friendly staff with a knowledge of the flavors, Prompt service, Out door service and delivery and seating. Just like grandma made Read more

Reviewed by
The Critical J.

October 07, 2023

PROS: this is still my top ice cream place in the area. The ice cream tastes good, prices are unbeatable, staff is nice, and the service is now very quick CONS: they closed off the inside you... Read more

Reviewed by
Christine K.

October 31, 2022

My family and I had often read great things about Mr. G's, so when we told a relative that we were going to be heading into Gettysburg for the day, he said we NEEDED to make a stop especially for... Read more

View 170 reviews on