user rating
4.5 / 5
67 votes
Food & Drink

Captain Tonys Saloon

428 Greene St, Key West, Florida 33040 USA (305) 294-1838

  • Restaurant
  • Dive Bar
  • American Food
  • Historic Site
  • Literature
  • Local Dining
  • Bar

Tip: review this place & help build a better community!

  • Independent
  • Credit Cards Accepted
  • Pet Friendly
  • Wheelchair Accessible
  • No Wifi
  • Street Parking
  • Restrooms
Rated 4.0 July 2, 2014 Top Review!

This bar is awesome and certainly put the Sloppy Joe's on Duval Street to shame, not so much because it does something much better, but the ambiance is more authentic here. It's a nice place to grab a couple of drinks after enjoying some fish tacos across the street. There's usually live music, too!

  • Reply
  • Was this helpful? Yes 2

Captain Tonys Saloon

428 Greene St
Key West, Florida 33040 USA

(305) 294-1838

Your rating:

Favorite watering hole of such legends as Ernest Hemingway, Truman Capote, Tennessee Williams, Shel Silverstein and Jimmy Buffet, Captain Tony’s Saloon is not just a bar it is a piece of living history. The saloon’s namesake, fishing boat captain gunrunner, gambling casino operator and Mayor of Key West the late Captain Tony, was a larger than life character who was often described as a dropout from a Hemingway novel.

Originally built in 1851 as an icehouse that doubled as a morgue Captain Tony’s Saloon is steeped in history. When you stop  in for a cold one, remember you are drinking where legends have been drinking for decades.

  • Reply
  • Was this helpful? Yes 1
Rated 4.0 August 31, 2014

Ernest Hemingway, Truman Capote, Shel Silverstein, Tennessee Williams and the Mayor of Margaritaville himself, Jimmy Buffet, have all enjoyed a drink (or 10) at Captain Tony's Saloon in Key West, Florida. What the tourist guide books often fail to note is the fact that the dive bar used to be a morgue. In fact, there are still bodies buried underneath the bar stools.

Read full article here
  • Reply
  • Was this helpful? Yes 1
August 12, 2014

Nice little bar. there is even a tree in it! !! lots of bras & money nailed to the ceiling. very local, laid back.

  • Reply
  • Was this helpful? Yes 1
Rated 5.0 July 14, 2014

Of all of the popular bars in Key West, this was by far the most comfortable for a midday drink, which was surprisingly good! I recommend the Captain Tony's Amber Ale if you've had enough rum. If you stick around long enough, you might find a business card, dollar, or bra that belongs to someone you know.

  • Reply
  • Was this helpful? Yes 1
Rated 5.0 March 14, 2015

The best a bar can get ins Key West.

  • Reply
  • Was this helpful? Yes 0
Rated 4.0 March 7, 2015

Fun alcohol selections. Their Rhum punch is a must try.

  • Reply
  • Was this helpful? Yes 0