Carmen & David's Creamery

For years, walking around this fair city, Carmen and David wished someone would open a good, old fashioned ice cream shop: “What this town needs is a good, old fashioned ice cream shop” they would say to themselves. Well, sometimes, if you want a thing done you really do have to do it yourself! Carmen & David's Creamery found an ideal home at 25 North Prince Street across the street from the Fulton Opera House and the Ware Center at Millersville University-Lancaster. At any one time, we carry 30 flavors of rich, creamy ultra premium ice cream, sherbet and sorbet. This always includes a sugar free ice cream flavor. There are standard and seasonal flavors and some very unique special flavors like Molasses, Cleo’s Addiction and Holy Mole that have been developed by Carmen and David. We offer cones, dishes, sundaes, milkshakes, ice cream sodas, floats and coolers, as well as our own special blend of coffee, prepared in a French Press. We proudly serve locally brewed Kutztown sodas, old fashioned flavors in bottles and on tap. In the summer we brew our own iced tea and Meadow Tea. When the weather turns cool we serve hot spiced cider. When it gets really cold, David turns out the best hot chocolate you’ve ever had – definitely for grown-ups! We are proud to say that EVERY scoop of ice cream served at the Creamery is made right here. We use only the finest ingredients available, locally sourced whenever possible. YES! We make it HERE! Come in & Taste the Difference!