Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill St

New York style pizza is large, hand tossed and has a thin crisp yet foldable crust. Goodfellas has mastered this art and presents it to you along with fresh ingredients, homemade sauce, and 100% whole milk mozzarella cheese. We thrive in a fast paced environment, with high energy music, and a friendly community of people gathered for one thing… good pizza. Have it by the slice or bring home a whole 22" pie for the entire family to enjoy. Capisce? Goodfellas has been serving pizza by the slice in the Lexington, Kentucky and the Greater Cincinnati area since 2005. Our pizza is gigantic, 22 inches, serving a true New York style pizza by the slice. Our dough is made fresh daily, hand tossed and baked off on the stone. Entertaining our guests is part of our service, tossing the dough and performing dough tricks to great energetic music is always a crowd pleaser.