Remove Ads

Eagle Deli

25 W Neck Rd, Shelter Island, New York 11964 USA

19 Reviews
$
Budget
Closed Now
Opens Fri 6a
  • Independent
  • Credit Cards
    Accepted

No Longer Maintained

This location is no longer maintained in Roadtrippers. Please confirm location details before visiting.

Remove Ads

Learn more about this business on Yelp.

The old crew is back, so come on down and say hello! Try our breakfast and lunch sandwiches made to order, daily lunch ,,,,SALAD AND MUCH MUCH MORE

Read More >
Photo of Baggio G.

Reviewed by
Baggio G.

UPDATE: I called to complain about the sandwiches and a separate issue and spoke to a woman. After she was getting loud with me, I told her I'm calm, why can't you be calm? She hung up on me. I... Read more

Photo of Charlie B.

Reviewed by
Charlie B.

Service is terrible. Lady on the phone is straight up mean. The pickle on the sandwich is a crime. What a decline in service. Don't go here. I will never go back. Read more

Photo of Tony D.

Reviewed by
Tony D.

Everything was great here little pricey but what isn't on shelter island... It was 14 dollars for a sandwich and chips. Clean but small inside easy to pass it by. Would go to again Read more

Eagle Deli

25 W Neck Rd
Shelter Island, New York
11964 USA
Remove Ads

Hours

Closed Now
  • Sun - Sat: 6:00 am - 5:00 pm

Problem with this listing? Let us know.

Has RV parking changed? Let us know.

Remove Ads
  • Unavailable
    Parking
  • Unknown
    Pets Allowed
  • Unknown
    Restrooms
  • Unknown
    Wifi
  • Unknown
    Wheelchair Accessible
  • Check
    Credit Cards Accepted
Reservations
Does not take
  • Check
    Lunch
  • Check
    Breakfast
See More Details (10)

Parking, Dining

Remove Ads

Nearby Hotels

Southold, New York
FastBook
$$

Click to discover a
great deal!

Riverhead, New York
East Marion, New York
East Hampton, New York
Southampton, New York
Remove Ads

Related Trip Guides

Remove Ads
4647049