Tent Camping Versus Car Camping Compared

At 2am in a downpour the contrast is stark. In a tent you’re checking for leaks and guy lines, hoping your sleeping mat isn’t soaked. In a car you can open a window and move a blanket around and wait it out. In good weather at an interesting spot off the main road (under some big trees, at a scenic viewpoint etc) a tent provides a base for spending time there. It’s not a question of ‘roughing it’ vs an easier alternative. It’s about the appropriate base for the trip you’re doing and who you’re doing it with, and the interesting places you hope to discover off the main road. The term ‘car camping’ is confusing as there are two definitions. For some it describes driving to a campsite and setting up a tent, chairs, camp stove, cooler etc. For others it involves sleeping in the car, SUV, truck bed, van and so on.

What tent camping and car camping really mean

In this context car camping means sleeping in your vehicle and tent camping involves sleeping in a tent at an existing campsite or somewhere you’ve parked up to do the above. Both allow you to do significant traveling, take far more gear with you than in a backpack and make interesting side trips where a sign on the main road suggests something interesting to see or do nearby.

Neither is superior to the other. A family with a dog and two children may find a large tent at a state park ideal. Someone doing a trip moving hotel or campsite nightly may find sleeping in a small SUV far more suitable. It depends on the vehicle, the weather, the rules of the campsite and how much you want to have to ‘set up’ camp. Car camping provides an immediate means of getting out of bad weather or being in a suitable climate. You have a known enclosed space with hard walls and a locking door. It’s often ideal after a long day of driving or as a one night stop on a trip.

Tent camping versus car camping: the practical differences

Comfort depends on the night, not just the mattress

The downside is that very few vehicles are designed to be slept in. Unless you have a van, truck camper or an SUV with flat loading seats you are sleeping on an unlevel surface with very little ability to turn around. If windows are shut it gets very damp, open windows mean bugs, noise and cold air coming in. Do not sleep in a vehicle while it’s running or idle it for heat or AC in a confined or unventilated space due to risk of carbon monoxide poisoning.

A tent provides much more space to live in or move around in. In most family tents you can stand up in them, comfortably change clothes and leave muddy boots in the ‘porch’ area. With a decent sleeping mat and appropriate sleeping bag for the weather it’s often much more comfortable than the back of a car. It requires more effort around finding a level pitch, dealing with water running off the tent, needing to be staked out and accepting you will hear or be heard at the campsite.

Setup time favors the vehicle

If doing this in near darkness, car camping is the better option. Park up legally, get screens/shades in the windows, sort out your sleeping gear and you’re pretty much ready to go. It’s ideal if you want to do other things in daylight at the site or nearby (short walks, visit local diners/overlooks etc).

Tent camping involves finding a suitable flat area and clearing minor obstructions around it, pitching the tent, sorting out sleeping pads/gear. This all gets dismantled in the morning. Once you’ve got a routine around it it’s fairly quick but not effortless.

The benefit is that the car is now free to use. You can leave the tent pitched and drive from the site to a nearby walk, town or scenic drive. You don’t have to pack your sleeping quarters back in the car to do this. This is useful if staying more than a night.

Campsite access is more complicated than it looks

You can take a tent elsewhere, including walk-in sites and some remote areas inaccessible by car. It’s also the standard option for state/family campgrounds and campgrounds in National Forests which are designed around providing a site with a fire pit and access to other outdoor facilities.

You can often do this in a suitable designated car parking area but not everywhere you can park a car. Most places you can park overnight have further restrictions on this. Often these won’t be suitable places to actually get a decent night’s sleep.

You should view this as separate from a campsite. In advance of visiting a site you need to check the specific rules for that location, any other signage/local bylaws and details of your booking. Don’t assume because you can park in a quiet spot that you can stay overnight there. It’s far nicer than being disturbed in the morning to do this. If you have a vehicle suitable for this anyway, it’s a good low cost way to begin.

Cost can tilt either way

You probably just need some screens/shades for the windows, a sleeping pad and bag and some means of storing gear in the car to do this for a weekend. It also means you don’t feel the need to buy all the related camping comforts at once.

There is more involved gear required for tent camping (a tent, footprint, pegs, sleeping mats and a lantern). For longer camping trips you often also have a larger shelter and table area. Tents range hugely in price and a decent basic one will last you a long time. It also means you don’t have to change your vehicle for camping purposes unless you do it frequently.

Fees for a campsite don’t necessarily differ based on how you sleep at camp. A vehicle site, standard campsite and tent site often cost the same. Some sites require/charge extra for additional vehicles. Read the description of the site rather than just the title of the site.

Pick based on your route and how you like to travel

Car camping is great for short trips, trips in the off season, or trips for one/two people with multiple overnight stops. It’s very simple to set up, keeps your gear handy and largely dictates an early start the next morning. An example would be a long weekend driving the Blue Ridge Parkway stopping in small towns just long enough to sleep before moving on to the next scenic spot.

Tent camping is more appropriate where the campsite is a destination in its own right. You might be staying in one place for a few nights near a National Park, want to cook outside or have space for kids to play around the campsite. Or you’re traveling in a large group and the car would be incredibly cramped. A tent provides space to do this and allows a more defined transition from a day of driving to spending an evening at camp.

Often a combination is best. Take a tent but set the car up so you can sleep in it if necessary. This provides a fallback if the weather turns nasty or you get to camp too late in the day to put a tent up. Otherwise you spend the evening in the tent and have the extra space.

Gear that makes either option better

You want a tent that provides a useful purpose beyond just occupying space. This includes an appropriately specified tent and a manageable groundsheet, good sleeping pads and a warm set of clothes solely for use at camp. You don’t need a large tent if you are moving camp every morning. A smaller tent you are familiar with will be much easier to put up in bad light or in windy conditions.

If sleeping in the car you want a comfortable place to lie flat with privacy and access to fresh air. Screens and reflective covers for the windows, a fan you can run from a battery and suitable storage boxes make this far more pleasant. Ensure you have an unobstructed way to get into the driving position and that gear isn’t preventing access to windows/emergency exits.

In both cases take a headlamp, water, basic first aid, appropriate warm clothing and a means of securing your food. Do exactly what the campground says about storing food. Leaving a cooler out or food in a tent can ruin your night.

Plan your stops around realistic driving days. Roadtrippers are good for identifying other things to see/do, places to stop for food/fuel etc so you aren’t looking for somewhere to spend the night once it’s dark.

A better question than which one wins

Consider what you want to do at the campsite. Do you want to pull in late, have a quiet night and drive at daybreak across the next state border? In that case you might spend the night in the car.

Do you want to camp under the trees, listen to the creek and wake up with time to do something before moving on? In that case put the tent up.

Build some flexibility around this. The best trips aren’t very set. It gives you an excuse to take the ‘scenic route’ exit off the road.